‘Project Hail Mary’ Author Andy Weir Critiques Paramount’s ‘Star Trek’ Efforts, Claims Rejected Pitch: “Their Shows Are Sh**”
Andy Weir Takes Aim at Modern ‘Star Trek’
Bestselling author Andy Weir, known for his novel Project Hail Mary, has voiced strong criticism regarding Paramount+’s current Star Trek offerings. During a recent appearance on the Critical Drinker podcast, Weir expressed disappointment with the direction of modern Trek shows, stating that they lack the innovative spirit of the original series.
Weir’s comments came in response to a discussion about the success of Project Hail Mary, which has resonated with audiences who grew up watching Star Trek. He noted that many fans feel a void in quality science fiction content today.
Critique of Current Star Trek Shows
Weir referenced an unnamed analyst who remarked that while modern science fiction has been heavily influenced by the original Star Trek, the latest iterations of the franchise seem to diverge significantly from that legacy. He emphasized that this disconnect is evident in the storytelling and character development of the current Star Trek series.
Reflecting on his own experiences, Weir shared that he grew up watching reruns of the original Star Trek and Lost in Space, noting a lack of new science fiction during that time until the arrival of Star Trek: The Next Generation.
Discussion on Starfleet Academy Cancellation
The conversation also touched on the recent cancellation of Star Trek: Starfleet Academy, which Paramount+ confirmed will conclude after its second season. Weir and podcast host Will Jordan shared a moment of levity regarding the show’s demise, with Weir humorously stating, “It’s gone baby! It’s all gone.”
Jordan suggested that Paramount should consider de-canonizing all Star Trek content from Enterprise onward, a sentiment that Weir found to be a bit extreme. However, he did express his enjoyment of Strange New Worlds and found Lower Decks to be entertaining, while expressing dissatisfaction with many of the other recent Trek projects.
Weir’s Rejected Pitch to Paramount
Weir revealed that he had pitched a Star Trek show to Paramount, participating in discussions with showrunners and executive producer Alex Kurtzman. Despite his positive view of Kurtzman as a person, Weir was candid about his feelings toward the new Trek series, stating, “Those shows are sh**.” He expressed frustration that his pitch was not accepted.
As reported by www.hollywoodreporter.com, Paramount has yet to respond to Weir’s comments.
Current Status of Star Trek Productions
Currently, Paramount+ appears to be in a transitional phase regarding its Star Trek projects. For the first time in years, there are no new Trek series in production, although there are still two seasons of Strange New Worlds and one season of Starfleet Academy left to air.
Speculation surrounds the future of Alex Kurtzman, who has been at the helm of the Star Trek revival. His contract with CBS Studios is set to expire at the end of 2026, and discussions are ongoing about renewing or extending his deal with Paramount+.
Open Letter Addressing Criticism
Following the announcement of Starfleet Academy’s cancellation, Kurtzman, along with executive producers Noga Landau and Gaia Violo, issued an open letter addressing criticisms of the show. The letter emphasized the importance of Star Trek as a cultural touchstone, highlighting its commitment to exploring themes of optimism and human potential.
The letter stated, “Whether you’re working on Star Trek or part of the marvel that is Star Trek fandom — its very heart, soul, and conscience — the joy comes from adventuring across boundaries of time, space, and the humanly possible in service to [Gene] Roddenberry’s transformative vision of the future.”
It further elaborated on Roddenberry’s dual message of hope and warning, urging fans and creators alike to reflect on humanity’s potential and challenges.
Explore the latest digital editions of FAME Delivered in the Magazine section.
Published on 2026-03-29 03:23:00 • By FAME Delivered News Desk