‘Pizza Movie’ Filmmakers BriTANick Strengthen Their Marketing Strategy with a Creative Twist Inspired by ‘Marty Supreme’

Nick Kocher and Brian McElhaney, the creative duo behind the film Pizza Movie, are aware that their title may not be the most captivating for their feature directorial debut. The former SNL writers, known collectively as BriTANick, initially struggled to name their “stoner comedy for theater kids,” which stars Stranger Things actor Gaten Matarazzo. The working title of Untitled Pizza Movie eventually evolved into the final title.

Title Evolution and Creative Inspiration

The filmmakers found the title more endearing once they incorporated a joke into the film that pays off unexpectedly. McElhaney shared that they conducted numerous polls among friends, but no title garnered unanimous approval. He recalled expressing his disdain for the title, stating, “We cannot call this Pizza Movie! That is the worst title in the world.” Kocher later reflected on how the joke transformed his feelings about the title, saying, “Now I deeply love it because it is all the setup for this punchline 83 minutes into the movie.”

Pizza Movie follows the hallucinatory misadventures of Jack (Matarazzo), Montgomery (Sean Giambrone), and Lizzy (Lulu Wilson) as they attempt to retrieve a pizza from their college dorm lobby to counteract the effects of an experimental drug they consumed. The film is a Hulu release, highlighting the unfortunate trend of comedy struggling at the box office. BriTANick was aware from the outset that their film would be a streaming release, although they did explore the possibility of a theatrical run.

Marketing Strategy Inspired by Timothée Chalamet

In a creative twist, the filmmakers decided to poke fun at their lack of a theatrical release by drawing inspiration from Timothée Chalamet’s Marty Supreme promotional campaign. Instead of a grand venue, Matarazzo and Giambrone stood atop a picnic table to humorously express their disappointment over not securing a big-screen release. Kocher and McElhaney credited Hulu for their willingness to embrace the joke.

“Hulu was totally down for it,” McElhaney explained. “They knew that we wanted it to be in theaters; we’d had the conversation before.” The filmmakers managed to shoot the promotional spot quickly while attending press events during South by Southwest.

Kocher believes that the decline of comedy at the box office is partly due to the genre’s prevalence on social media. He noted that they have contributed to this shift through their work on the BriTANick YouTube channel and other comedic platforms. “We’re complaining about the thing that we began,” McElhaney remarked, acknowledging the dual nature of social media as both a facilitator and a distraction for emerging comedians.

Upcoming Projects and Collaborations

Despite the challenges faced by comedies in theaters, BriTANick has a theatrical release scheduled for April 24. They wrote Over Your Dead Body, directed by Jorma Taccone and starring Samara Weaving and Jason Segal. The film is a remake of Tommy Wirkola’s Norwegian dark comedy-thriller, The Trip (2021). Kocher expressed excitement about working with Taccone, stating, “He’s been such an influence on us, and we all had an immediate shorthand.”

The filmmakers also discussed the unique casting process for Pizza Movie, emphasizing their desire to audition everyone rather than make offers. Matarazzo read for both lead roles, and his audition for Jack stood out. McElhaney noted that Matarazzo’s enthusiasm and insight during the script revisions were invaluable.

The Role of Humor and AI in Storytelling

In Pizza Movie, Daniel Radcliffe voices a butterfly named Lysander, a character that evolved from a minor role to one with a significant monologue. Kocher shared that they had a mutual connection with Radcliffe, which facilitated his involvement. “He came back with an immediate and enthusiastic yes,” Kocher said, praising Radcliffe’s commitment to the role.

The filmmakers also explored the film’s thematic elements, including the portrayal of RAs as antagonists. McElhaney explained that they drew inspiration from their college experiences, stating, “We said, ‘Let’s treat them as if they are the Orcs of the Lord of the Rings world or the roving Nazis of Inglourious Basterds.’”

Future Directions and Creative Aspirations

Looking ahead, Kocher and McElhaney expressed a desire to continue writing and directing, with plans to explore various genres. They are currently working on a project at New Line, which presents a different creative challenge. McElhaney highlighted the importance of balancing their unique sensibility with the desire to branch out into new styles.

As reported by www.hollywoodreporter.com, Pizza Movie is now streaming on Hulu, while Over Your Dead Body opens in theaters on April 24.

Explore the latest digital editions of FAME Delivered in the Magazine section.

Published on 2026-04-04 02:07:00 • By FAME Delivered News Desk